Which Contraception (Birth Control) Is Best for PMDD? The Pill, the Mini Pill and the Copper Coil, Compared
In the best trials, a combined pill containing drospirenone helped somewhere between 39% and 58% of women with PMDD, against 36% on a dummy pill. That is the honest number, from the 2023 Cochrane review, and it is the place to start, because almost everything else you will read about contraception and PMDD is either louder than that or a forum post.
I live with BPD and I am not a clinician. What follows is what NICE's own summary for GPs says, what the trials actually found, and where the gaps are, so that you can walk into the appointment knowing which questions to ask. If your question is the other way round, whether the pill or a coil can cause PMDD, that has its own page: can the pill or the coil cause PMDD.
The short version:
- First choice if you want hormonal contraception anyway: a combined pill with drospirenone and a low oestrogen dose, possibly taken back to back without the monthly break.
- Gambles rather than treatments: the hormonal coil (Mirena and similar), the mini pill, the implant and the injection. Some women are fine on them. Some feel much worse, and there is no way to know which you are without trying and tracking.
- The neutral option: the copper coil. No hormones, so no effect on PMDD either way.
Why does contraception change PMDD at all?
PMDD is not a hormone deficiency. It is a sensitivity to the normal rise and fall of the hormones in an ovulatory cycle. I have written about that properly in what PMDD actually is, but one study is worth knowing here because it explains nearly everything about choosing contraception.
In 2017, researchers at the US National Institute of Mental Health took 22 women with PMDD and switched their ovaries off with a GnRH agonist. Twelve went into remission. Those twelve were then given steady, continuous oestrogen and progesterone. Symptoms came back in the first month, when the levels rose from low to high, and then settled again in months two and three while the levels stayed level. The authors concluded that it was the change in hormone levels, not the steady level, that set the symptoms off (Schmidt et al., PMID 28427285).
Hold that in mind and the rest of this page makes sense. A method that stops ovulation and keeps hormone levels flat has a reason to help. A method that leaves your own cycle running, and adds a progestogen on top, has a reason to do nothing or to make things worse.
Does the combined pill help PMDD?
It can, and it is the hormonal option with the most evidence behind it. But the size of the effect is more modest than the confidence it is usually handed over with.
The 2023 Cochrane review (Ma and Song, PMID 37365881) pooled five randomised trials and 858 women, most of them diagnosed with PMDD. Pills containing drospirenone and ethinylestradiol:
- improved overall premenstrual symptoms, with what the authors called a small to moderate effect
- improved the knock-on damage to productivity, social life and relationships
- raised the response rate from 36% on placebo to between 39% and 58%
And the costs, which matter just as much:
- about 3% of women on placebo dropped out because of side effects, against 6% to 16% on the pill
- side effects of any kind went from 28% on placebo to 40% to 54%, mainly breast pain, nausea and bleeding between periods
- nobody knows whether it keeps working beyond three cycles, because the trials stopped there
- no trial has compared drospirenone pills with other pills
The authors also noted that the placebo itself had a significant effect. That is not an insult to anyone. It means that taking PMDD seriously, tracking it and being looked after measurably helps, and it means a trial of anything needs a symptom diary to tell you what actually changed.
One older industry-funded analysis of 449 women on the 20 microgram drospirenone pill found the biggest improvement came in the first cycle and held through cycles two and three, across low mood, food cravings and bloating (Marr et al., PMID 21664515). So you should know within two or three months whether it is doing anything.
Which pill is best for PMDD in the UK?
This is where NICE's Clinical Knowledge Summaries, the guidance GPs actually read, are unusually specific. CKS says:
- the evidence is strongest for combined pills containing drospirenone and ethinylestradiol, specifically the lower 20 microgram oestrogen dose
- in the UK, the only pill equivalent to the ones most studied is currently Eloine (drospirenone 3 mg and ethinylestradiol 20 micrograms), taken as 24 active pills then 4 placebo
- it is off-label if it is being used only for premenstrual symptoms, which is legal and common, but worth knowing
- other drospirenone and new-generation pills may also work, especially one you have already found helpful
- it is not possible to predict whether your symptoms will respond
CKS places the pill as an option once lifestyle changes have not been enough, alongside an SSRI and a referral for CBT. Those other two routes are covered in PMDD treatment in the UK. If you need contraception anyway, the pill is the one choice that may treat the PMDD at the same time.
The combined pill is not safe for everyone. The NHS says the risk of a blood clot is very small, affecting up to 1 in 1,000 people using combined hormonal contraception, and your GP will check things like migraine with aura, smoking and blood pressure before prescribing. That conversation is theirs to have with you, and it is not a formality.
Should I take the pill back to back without a break?
Possibly. CKS says current data suggest taking the combined pill continuously rather than cyclically, while noting that breakthrough bleeding may make that hard to stick with.
The reasoning is the Schmidt study above. The monthly pill-free week is a small withdrawal and restart of hormones, which is exactly the kind of change PMDD reacts to.
But I would be misleading you if I said the trials had settled it. A 2017 randomised trial of 55 women with confirmed PMDD compared placebo, the standard 21 days on and 7 off, and continuous use of the same drospirenone pill. All three groups improved by a similar amount, with a marked placebo response, and the authors wrote that the study failed to replicate a special benefit of continuous dosing (Eisenlohr-Moul et al., PMID 28715852).
So: reasonable to ask for, not a guarantee, and a symptom diary is how you find out whether it helps you.
Does the Mirena coil help PMDD?
There is no trial showing that it treats PMDD, and there are reasons to be careful.
The NHS describes the hormonal coil (brands include Mirena, Levosert, Kyleena, Jaydess and Benilexa) as releasing progestogen into the womb, lasting 3 to 8 years depending on type. Compare that with the NHS pages for the combined pill and the mini pill, which both say they work by stopping the ovaries releasing an egg. The coil page does not say that. For most users the cycle, which is the thing PMDD reacts to, keeps running.
What it adds is a progestogen. A 2019 review of contraception counselling in PMDD (Rapkin et al., PMID 31572029) lists the levonorgestrel coil among the progestogen-only methods that have the potential to negatively affect mood, in women with or without existing mood problems, and recommends careful counselling and close follow-up for anyone with PMDD who chooses one.
The NHS is cautious in the other direction: it says some people report mood changes on the hormonal coil, but there is not enough evidence to say whether the coil causes them. Both statements can be true. The average user may be fine while a woman who is sensitive to progestogens is not, and PMDD is, more or less by definition, a sensitivity to hormonal change.
Where the hormonal coil does have a genuine role is as the progestogen part of HRT, which the NHS lists as one of its uses. Specialists sometimes use oestrogen to suppress the cycle with a coil protecting the womb lining, which is a different strategy from using the coil alone. And if you have a hormonal coil, no periods, and symptoms that still arrive on a schedule, that is a recognised pattern with its own explanation in can the pill or the coil cause PMDD. If the oestrogen route is where you are heading, the details are in PMDD treatment in the UK and, for the later years, in does PMDD go away after the menopause.
Will the mini pill, the implant or the injection help?
None of them is a recognised PMDD treatment.
The mini pill is a slightly odd case. The NHS says the progestogen-only pill does stop ovulation, so in theory it removes the cycle. But it does that with a progestogen and no oestrogen, and the 2019 review puts the mini pill, the implant and the injection in the same group as the hormonal coil: methods with the potential to worsen mood. The NHS lists mood swings among reported side effects of the mini pill while saying the evidence is not strong enough to say it causes them.
The best large-scale data on mood come from Denmark. A study of 1,061,997 women aged 15 to 34 compared the rate of starting an antidepressant for the first time in users of each method against non-users (Skovlund et al., PMID 27680324):
| Method | Relative rate of first antidepressant |
|---|---|
| Combined pill | 1.23 |
| Progestogen-only pill | 1.34 |
| Hormonal coil | 1.4 |
| Vaginal ring | 1.6 |
| Patch | 2.0 |
The rates were higher in teenagers: 1.8 on the combined pill and 2.2 on the mini pill for 15 to 19 year olds. Two important limits: this study was about all women, not women with PMDD, and it shows a link rather than proving the contraception caused the depression. Women who already had depression were excluded. What it does tell you is that no hormonal method is guaranteed mood-neutral, and that the first six months are when to watch, because that is when the rate peaked.
Is the copper coil the safest choice with PMDD?
If what you want is contraception that will not touch your PMDD, yes. The NHS says the copper coil does not use hormones, works as soon as it is put in, and lasts 5 or 10 years depending on the type. The 2019 review recommends it for women with PMDD who are not looking for hormonal contraception.
It will not treat your PMDD either. Your cycle carries on exactly as before. And the NHS says periods may become heavier, longer or more painful, which may improve after a few months. If heavy or painful periods are already part of your premenstrual weeks, that is a real cost to weigh.
How do I tell whether a method is helping or making it worse?
The same way PMDD is diagnosed: daily ratings, not memory. CKS says the effect of treatment should be judged with a validated diary such as the Daily Record of Severity of Problems, with a review after about two months.
That matters more for contraception than for almost anything else, because:
- many side effects are worst in the first few months, so one bad month is not the full answer
- the placebo response in every trial was large, so feeling better is real but you want to know what changed
- a progestogen-related worsening can look exactly like your usual PMDD, just longer, and only a chart shows the difference
You can use the free PMDD symptom tracker on this site, start it a cycle before you change anything, and take two or three cycles of it to your review. If a new method gives you darker or longer low weeks, or any thoughts of harming yourself, do not wait for the review. Go back to your GP, and if things feel unsafe now, contact Samaritans on 116 123 at any hour.
What to say at the appointment
- "I have PMDD [or suspected PMDD]. NICE CKS says drospirenone pills, specifically Eloine, have the most evidence. Is that suitable for me?"
- "Could I take it continuously rather than with a break each month?"
- "If I need a coil, I would rather start with the copper one, because the reviews say progestogen-only methods can worsen mood in PMDD."
- "Can we review in two to three months against my symptom diary?"
If you have not been diagnosed yet, how to get a PMDD diagnosis in the UK walks through what a GP needs to see.
If you are planning a pregnancy, what happens to PMDD then and after the baby is covered in can the pill or the coil cause PMDD.
Sources
- NICE Clinical Knowledge Summaries, Premenstrual syndrome: Management, last revised September 2024 (cks.nice.org.uk), read 18 October 2026.
- Ma S, Song SJ. Oral contraceptives containing drospirenone for premenstrual syndrome. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2023. PMID 37365881.
- Schmidt PJ et al. Premenstrual dysphoric disorder symptoms following ovarian suppression: triggered by change in ovarian steroid levels but not continuous stable levels. American Journal of Psychiatry 2017. PMID 28427285.
- Eisenlohr-Moul TA et al. Treatment of premenstrual dysphoria with continuous versus intermittent dosing of oral contraceptives. Depression and Anxiety 2017. PMID 28715852.
- Marr J et al. PMDD symptom cluster improvement by cycle with ethinylestradiol 20 mcg plus drospirenone 3 mg in a 24/4 regimen. Contraception 2011. PMID 21664515.
- Rapkin AJ et al. Contraception counseling for women with premenstrual dysphoric disorder: current perspectives. Open Access Journal of Contraception 2019. PMID 31572029.
- Skovlund CW et al. Association of hormonal contraception with depression. JAMA Psychiatry 2016. PMID 27680324.
- NHS, contraception pages for the copper coil (IUD), hormonal coil (IUS), progestogen-only pill and combined pill, read 18 October 2026.
Nothing here is medical advice, it's lived experience, meant to sit alongside real support, not replace it. If you're struggling, please see the support resources. If you're in crisis in the UK or Ireland, call Samaritans free on 116 123. In the US, call or text 988; in Canada, call or text 9-8-8; in Australia, call Lifeline on 13 11 14; in New Zealand, call or text 1737. In an emergency, dial 999 (UK), 112 or 999 (Ireland), 911 (US and Canada), 000 (Australia) or 111 (New Zealand).